Comparison

ShieldIngress vs Cloudflare

Cloudflare is a full network platform -- DNS, CDN, WAF, Workers, Zero Trust, and a lot more. ShieldIngress is one thing: a fully managed WAF and ingress layer for your websites. Here's an honest look at how they actually differ, plan by plan.

The short version

At the entry level the two cost about the same: ShieldIngress Basic is $19.99/mo, and Cloudflare Pro is $20/mo billed annually ($25 month to month). The difference is what that money buys. On ShieldIngress it's the whole security toolkit -- the managed OWASP ruleset, rate limits by path, method and country, path-scoped bot challenges, and log-only "try it first" modes -- set up for you. On Cloudflare Pro, several of those are capped low or only arrive on Business ($200/mo per domain) or Enterprise.

If you want one platform that also runs your DNS, a global CDN, serverless compute, and Zero Trust access, and you're comfortable configuring it yourself, Cloudflare's breadth and scale are real advantages. They're not really solving the same problem.

Pricing

PlanShieldIngressCloudflare
Free tierNo (7-day free trial instead)Yes, $0
Entry paid plan$19.99/mo (Basic, 1 domain)$20/mo annual, $25 monthly (Pro, per domain)
Top self-serve plan$129.99/mo (Pro, up to 10 domains)$200/mo annual, $250 monthly (Business, per domain)
10 domains on the top self-serve plan$129.99/mo total$2,000/mo or more (priced per domain)
Load balancingIncluded in ProPaid add-on, from $5/mo

Cloudflare's Free plan is a genuinely useful CDN and DDoS layer, with a small free WAF ruleset and 5 custom rules -- there's no $0 ShieldIngress equivalent. Where they diverge is what you pay for more than that: on Cloudflare the full managed ruleset starts at Pro, and every domain is its own plan; on ShieldIngress everything below is included from the first dollar, and Pro covers ten domains for one price.

WAF and rate limiting

FeatureShieldIngress (Basic / Pro)Cloudflare (Free / Pro / Business)
OWASP Core Rule SetEvery planPro and up (Free gets a smaller free ruleset)
Custom WAF rules10 / 50 per rule type, plus a visual Rule Builder5 / 20 / 100
Try a rule in log-only mode firstEvery plan, and preview it against your real traffic before saving"Log" action is Enterprise only
Rate limiting rules10 / 501 / 2 / 5
Rate limit by HTTP method or countryEvery planMethod from Business; country counting Enterprise only
IP, CIDR & country blockingEvery plan, with ready-made country groupsEvery plan

Bots, traffic and operations

FeatureShieldIngressCloudflare
Bot challengeJavaScript, proof-of-work, or slider -- scoped to just the paths being hitBot Fight Mode (Free), Super Bot Fight Mode (Pro/Business), full Bot Management (Enterprise)
Challenge only while your origin is overloadedYes (Overload Protection)No direct equivalent
Revision history with diff & one-click rollbackEvery planAudit log on all plans; config versioning is Enterprise
Staging deploy before productionProEnterprise
WAF events & traffic logs with CSV exportEvery planYes (dashboard, plus Logpush; datasets vary by plan)
Automatic SSL certificatesYesYes
Global CDN & DDoS scaleFocused edge footprintOne of the largest networks in the world
DNS hosting, Workers, Zero TrustNot offeredYes

Where Cloudflare genuinely wins

  • Scale and DDoS absorption. Cloudflare's network is one of the largest on the internet and absorbs very large volumetric attacks on every plan. No smaller provider matches that.
  • A free tier that's actually useful. CDN, DDoS protection, SSL, and a basic WAF at $0 is a legitimately good starting point for a low-stakes site.
  • Breadth. If you also need DNS hosting, serverless compute, or Zero Trust access control, having it all under one account is convenient -- assuming you have the time to configure it.
  • A written uptime SLA on Business and Enterprise.

Where ShieldIngress fits better

  • You want it configured correctly by default, not configured by you. The OWASP ruleset, security headers, and sensible rate limits come set up out of the box -- you're not assembling a policy from dozens of options spread across several products.
  • You want the advanced controls without the enterprise contract. Rate limits by method and country, log-only trials, per-path bot challenges, staging, and rollback are on self-serve plans, not behind a sales call.
  • You run several sites. Pro covers up to ten domains for $129.99/mo, instead of a separate plan for each one.
  • You want a straight line to support. When you email support, you're talking to the person who builds the product -- not a tiered ticket queue.

See it running against your own site first

7-day free trial on both Basic and Pro. Cancel any time.

Cloudflare prices and plan limits as published on cloudflare.com/plans and in Cloudflare's developer documentation for custom rules, rate limiting rules and managed rules, checked November 2026. Cloudflare's pricing and feature limits change over time; check their site for the current offering. ShieldIngress is not affiliated with or endorsed by Cloudflare, Inc.