The short version
At the entry level the two cost about the same: ShieldIngress Basic is $19.99/mo, and Cloudflare Pro is $20/mo billed annually ($25 month to month). The difference is what that money buys. On ShieldIngress it's the whole security toolkit -- the managed OWASP ruleset, rate limits by path, method and country, path-scoped bot challenges, and log-only "try it first" modes -- set up for you. On Cloudflare Pro, several of those are capped low or only arrive on Business ($200/mo per domain) or Enterprise.
If you want one platform that also runs your DNS, a global CDN, serverless compute, and Zero Trust access, and you're comfortable configuring it yourself, Cloudflare's breadth and scale are real advantages. They're not really solving the same problem.
Pricing
| Plan | ShieldIngress | Cloudflare |
|---|---|---|
| Free tier | No (7-day free trial instead) | Yes, $0 |
| Entry paid plan | $19.99/mo (Basic, 1 domain) | $20/mo annual, $25 monthly (Pro, per domain) |
| Top self-serve plan | $129.99/mo (Pro, up to 10 domains) | $200/mo annual, $250 monthly (Business, per domain) |
| 10 domains on the top self-serve plan | $129.99/mo total | $2,000/mo or more (priced per domain) |
| Load balancing | Included in Pro | Paid add-on, from $5/mo |
Cloudflare's Free plan is a genuinely useful CDN and DDoS layer, with a small free WAF ruleset and 5 custom rules -- there's no $0 ShieldIngress equivalent. Where they diverge is what you pay for more than that: on Cloudflare the full managed ruleset starts at Pro, and every domain is its own plan; on ShieldIngress everything below is included from the first dollar, and Pro covers ten domains for one price.
WAF and rate limiting
| Feature | ShieldIngress (Basic / Pro) | Cloudflare (Free / Pro / Business) |
|---|---|---|
| OWASP Core Rule Set | Every plan | Pro and up (Free gets a smaller free ruleset) |
| Custom WAF rules | 10 / 50 per rule type, plus a visual Rule Builder | 5 / 20 / 100 |
| Try a rule in log-only mode first | Every plan, and preview it against your real traffic before saving | "Log" action is Enterprise only |
| Rate limiting rules | 10 / 50 | 1 / 2 / 5 |
| Rate limit by HTTP method or country | Every plan | Method from Business; country counting Enterprise only |
| IP, CIDR & country blocking | Every plan, with ready-made country groups | Every plan |
Bots, traffic and operations
| Feature | ShieldIngress | Cloudflare |
|---|---|---|
| Bot challenge | JavaScript, proof-of-work, or slider -- scoped to just the paths being hit | Bot Fight Mode (Free), Super Bot Fight Mode (Pro/Business), full Bot Management (Enterprise) |
| Challenge only while your origin is overloaded | Yes (Overload Protection) | No direct equivalent |
| Revision history with diff & one-click rollback | Every plan | Audit log on all plans; config versioning is Enterprise |
| Staging deploy before production | Pro | Enterprise |
| WAF events & traffic logs with CSV export | Every plan | Yes (dashboard, plus Logpush; datasets vary by plan) |
| Automatic SSL certificates | Yes | Yes |
| Global CDN & DDoS scale | Focused edge footprint | One of the largest networks in the world |
| DNS hosting, Workers, Zero Trust | Not offered | Yes |
Where Cloudflare genuinely wins
- Scale and DDoS absorption. Cloudflare's network is one of the largest on the internet and absorbs very large volumetric attacks on every plan. No smaller provider matches that.
- A free tier that's actually useful. CDN, DDoS protection, SSL, and a basic WAF at $0 is a legitimately good starting point for a low-stakes site.
- Breadth. If you also need DNS hosting, serverless compute, or Zero Trust access control, having it all under one account is convenient -- assuming you have the time to configure it.
- A written uptime SLA on Business and Enterprise.
Where ShieldIngress fits better
- You want it configured correctly by default, not configured by you. The OWASP ruleset, security headers, and sensible rate limits come set up out of the box -- you're not assembling a policy from dozens of options spread across several products.
- You want the advanced controls without the enterprise contract. Rate limits by method and country, log-only trials, per-path bot challenges, staging, and rollback are on self-serve plans, not behind a sales call.
- You run several sites. Pro covers up to ten domains for $129.99/mo, instead of a separate plan for each one.
- You want a straight line to support. When you email support, you're talking to the person who builds the product -- not a tiered ticket queue.
See it running against your own site first
7-day free trial on both Basic and Pro. Cancel any time.
Cloudflare prices and plan limits as published on cloudflare.com/plans and in Cloudflare's developer documentation for custom rules, rate limiting rules and managed rules, checked November 2026. Cloudflare's pricing and feature limits change over time; check their site for the current offering. ShieldIngress is not affiliated with or endorsed by Cloudflare, Inc.